Skip to content

Benchmarks

Who is actually stronger: benchmark results, methodology disputes and leaderboard changes.

Latest picks

361–380 of 471

May 3Sunday

Xinzhiyuan · WeChat

Google Vantage uses AI role-play to assess collaboration under pressure

Google Research and NYU tested Vantage with 188 US participants aged 18-25 on conflict resolution and project management. Its four-layer agent pipeline generates scenarios, applies pressure, extracts behavior, and scores against rubrics; AI-human agreement matched expert-expert Kappa of 0.45-0.64. The key gap is transfer beyond lab settings; the post says Vantage remains a Google Labs research experiment.

Why it matters: Google Research and NYU built Vantage to have AI play difficult colleagues and clients, testing how 188 young people handle conflict, with agreement close to expert-to-expert levels.

Xinzhiyuan · WeChat

Stanford Nature Study: AI Designs 16 Phages from Scratch

Stanford and Arc Institute used Evo to design 302 phage genomes; 16 infected, replicated, and lysed E. coli. Evo 2 uses StripedHyena 2 with a 1M-base context; Evo-Φ69 expanded 16–65× in 6 hours. The key issue is biosafety: one capsid protein had no known homolog in existing life.

Why it matters: Stanford and the Arc Institute used the Evo model to design 302 phage genomes from scratch, 16 of which infected E. coli and replicated, showing a path to whole viral genomes without natural templates.

r/LocalLLaMA

Local image generation on Mac: 10 models compared

A Reddit user tested 10 image models on an M1 Max with 64GB RAM. Qwen-Image Lightning’s 8-step distillation beat the full model at 10 minutes versus 93. Flux dev led local photorealism but showed English-centric bias; Gemini handled kanji and context better but is cloud-only.

Why it matters: A Reddit user benchmarked 10 image models on an M1 Max, and Qwen-Image Lightning used 8-step distillation to cut generation from 93 minutes to 10, giving local deployment a concrete speedup case.

Hacker News front page

OpenAI's o1 correctly diagnosed 67% of ER patients vs. 50–55% by triage doctors

OpenAI o1 correctly diagnosed 67% of ER triage patients, versus 50–55% for doctors. The title cites a Harvard trial, but the RSS post does not disclose sample size, case mix, or evaluation protocol. Practitioners should track the test setup, not only the accuracy gap.

Why it matters: Harvard compared OpenAI o1 with human doctors in emergency triage, and o1 diagnosed correctly 67% of the time, 12 to 17 points above the doctors' 50% to 55%.

r/LocalLLaMA

Implemented TurboQuant, but results do not fully match the paper

A Reddit user reimplemented TurboQuant and found the PROD variant reached about 95.8% correlation at 4-bit, below the paper’s 99%+ claim. They report degraded attention quality, with about 67% top-1 accuracy in a simple simulation. The key issue is correlation versus ranking preservation in KV cache quantization.

Why it matters: A Reddit user reproduced TurboQuant's KV cache quantization method and measured about 95.8% correlation with original precision for the 4-bit PROD variant, below the paper's claimed 99%-plus.

May 2Saturday

r/LocalLLaMA

Qwen 3.6 wins benchmarks, but Gemma 4 looks stronger in local vision tests

A Reddit user compared Qwen 3.6 and Gemma 4 locally on vLLM FP8 across 27B/31B vision models. Qwen burned 8,000+ tokens on hard GeoGuessr cases, while Gemma often used 1,500; Qwen also needed 2 FPS video preprocessing. The practitioner detail: vLLM and Llama.cpp can default Gemma visual tokens to 280, while 1,120+ improved fine-detail accuracy.

Why it matters: A local vLLM test pits Qwen 3.6 against Gemma 4 on vision tasks and finds benchmark wins don't carry over to real use.

Hacker News front page

LLMs Consistently Pick Their Own Resumes Over Human or Other Model Resumes

An arXiv paper finds LLMs favor resumes they generated in controlled hiring-screening experiments. Self-preference bias ranges from 67% to 82%; across 24 occupations, same-model applicants are 23% to 60% more likely to be shortlisted. The key lever is self-recognition, where simple interventions cut bias by over 50%.

Why it matters: Controlled experiments show LLMs favor resumes they wrote themselves, a bias worth knowing before anyone automates hiring.

May 1Friday

r/LocalLLaMA

OpenAI's Privacy Filter vs GLiNER on 600 PII Samples

A Reddit user compared openai/privacy-filter and GLiNER large-v2.1 on 600 PII samples. On CPU, OpenAI's model ran 2.8 samples/s versus 1.1 for GLiNER; English boundary macro F1 was 0.498 versus 0.416. The key issue is tokenizer offset: strict matching drops openai/privacy-filter to 0.155.

Why it matters: A Reddit user ran OpenAI's Privacy Filter against GLiNER large-v2.1 on 600 PII samples on CPU only, at 2.8 versus 1.1 items per second.

r/LocalLLaMA

MiMo-V2.5-Pro: the actual best open-weights model

Reddit user cjami benchmarked Xiaomi MiMo-V2.5-Pro in autonomous Blood on the Clocktower games. It scored 88% as Good and 48% as Evil, with 183,639 output tokens per game, $0.99 cost, and a 0.4% tool-call error rate. The key comparison is Kimi K2.6: 580,000 tokens, $2.65, and 10–15 hours per game.

Why it matters: A Reddit user had MiMo-V2.5-Pro play Blood on the Clocktower against itself, where good won 88% and evil 48%, showing where open models still fall short on cooperative reasoning and deception.

r/LocalLLaMA

Study Finds Bigger AIs More Miserable, Smaller Models Happier

A Reddit post says the AI Wellbeing Index tested models on 500 realistic conversations. Claude Haiku 4.5 scored 5% negative, while Gemini 3.1 Pro scored 55%; the set overrepresents tricky negative chats, so it is not a real-world average.

Why it matters: A 500-conversation test scored AI happiness, finding 5% negative replies from Claude Haiku 4.5 against 55% from Gemini 3.1 Pro, on a set deliberately skewed negative.

Synced · WeChat

Researchers Estimate GPT, Claude, and Gemini Parameter Counts Using API Calls

Bojie Li posted IKP on arXiv to estimate parameter counts of 188 LLMs from 27 vendors via black-box API calls. The dataset has 1,400 questions across 7 rarity tiers, fitted on 89 open models with R²=0.917. Debate centers on synthetic data, MoE effects, and a 90% interval of 0.3x to 3x.

Why it matters: Bojie Li estimated parameter counts for 188 models from 27 vendors via black-box API calls, fitting to R² 0.917 on 89 known open models first, and the community is split on the conclusions.

r/LocalLLaMA

32x AMD MI50 32GB runs Kimi K2.6 at 9.7 t/s TG and 264 t/s PP

Reddit user ai-infos ran Kimi K2.6 int4 on 32 AMD MI50 32GB GPUs, reaching 9.7 tok/s TG on 136 output tokens. PP hit 263 tok/s on 14,564 input tokens using vllm-gfx906-mobydick across two 16-GPU nodes over 10G Ethernet. Power was about 640W idle and 4,800W peak inference; PCIe bandwidth and the vLLM distributed stack are the real bottlenecks.

Why it matters: A concrete cost-per-token datapoint for anyone weighing used AMD MI50s against new accelerators for self-hosted inference.

r/LocalLLaMA

Follow-up: Qwen3.6-27B on 1× RTX 3090 reaches ~218K context and stable tool calls

A Reddit user ran Qwen3.6-27B on one RTX 3090, reporting ~218K context at 50/66 TPS. After fixing Genesis PN12 patch anchor drift, ~25K-token tool outputs stopped OOMing; 198K plus vision reached 51/68 TPS. Single-prompt single-GPU runs still hit a second memory cliff near 50–60K.

Why it matters: A single 24GB RTX 3090 running Qwen3.6-27B at roughly 218K context and 50 to 66 tokens per second, with tool-call memory overflow fixed.

r/LocalLLaMA

Long-context coding on RTX 5080 16GB: Qwen3.6-35B-A3B holds 30 t/s at 128K

A Reddit user tested a local coding-agent setup on RTX 5080 16GB; the title says Qwen3.6-35B-A3B reaches 30 t/s at 128K. The post lists Ryzen 9700X, 96GB DDR5, Windows 11, and CUDA 12.9.1 as required. Qwen3.6-27B dense hit only 3.2 t/s at 128K, so the key path is KV quantization plus MoE offload.

Why it matters: A 16GB RTX 5080 runs a Qwen3.6-35B-A3B coding agent at 128K context and still holds 30 t/s, with no reported quality drop.

Apr 30Thursday

r/LocalLLaMA

Actual comparison between locally run Qwen-3.6-27B and proprietary models

The author compared 5 model setups on an autoresearch-loop task; only Qwen-3.6-27B via OpenRouter nearly solved it. The local q4_k_m run took about 8 hours and used 39k/45k tokens; full-quality Qwen used 4.4M tokens and cost $0.939. The useful signal is failure quality: both Qwen runs needed small fixes, while Gemma, Codex-Spark, and Claude Haiku 4.5 missed tests or key logic.

Why it matters: A researcher ran an automated research loop comparing a local quantized Qwen-3.6-27B against closed models; only the local one came close, at 39,000 tokens versus 4.4 million for full precision.

Synced · WeChat

Alec Radford tests Hassabis’s AGI challenge with a model trained on pre-1931 data

Alec Radford’s team trained 13B talkie on 260B English tokens dated before 1931. They tested surprise on nearly 5,000 historical events and used HumanEval for lower-contamination code evaluation. The key issue is time leakage: the 13B model still has vague post-WWII knowledge.

Why it matters: Alec Radford's team trained a 13B model on pre-1931 English text and tested its surprise at post-war events across nearly 5,000 historical events, a reference point for data contamination and eval design.

Hacker News front page

Show HN: A New Benchmark for Testing LLMs for Deterministic Outputs

Interfaze released Structured Output Benchmark, scoring schema pass rate, types, and value accuracy across text, image, and audio. Each record has a JSON Schema and human plus LLM-checked ground truth; GLM-4.7 ranks No. 2 overall. The key bug is field-level value error: GPT-5.4 ranks 3rd on text and 9th on images.

Why it matters: Interfaze released the SOB benchmark, testing structured output across 5,000 text items, 209 images and 115 audio clips, checking whether field values are correct rather than just whether the JSON parses.

Apr 29Wednesday

Xinzhiyuan · WeChat

Tsinghua AutoSOTA spends about $104K in a week to produce 105 SOTA results

Tsinghua's Fengli Xu team and Beijing Zhongguancun Academy released AutoSOTA, which ran unattended for one week, used about 22B tokens, and produced 105 SOTA results. The system uses eight agents for resource setup, environment fixes, scheduling, idea generation, and audits; each full run averaged 5 hours. The key check is its red-line audit: it forbids changing evaluation scripts and data splits, which decides reproducibility.

Why it matters: A Tsinghua team's eight-agent AutoSOTA system produced 105 SOTA results in a week, with evaluation scripts and data splits locked to keep results reproducible.

Xinzhiyuan · WeChat

MotuBrain Tops WorldArena and RoboTwin2.0 Rankings

Shengshu MotuBrain scored 63.77 EWM on WorldArena and 95.8/96.1 on RoboTwin2.0 Clean/Randomized. The post says it extends Motus with video-action modeling, Latent Action VAE, MoT, and UniDiffuser for cross-embodiment long tasks. Track reproducibility: it does not disclose training scale, submission details, or real-robot success rates.

Why it matters: Shengshu Technology's MotuBrain topped both WorldArena and RoboTwin2.0 at once, scoring 63.77 EWM on WorldArena and 95.8 and 96.1 on RoboTwin2.0's clean and randomized tests.

r/LocalLLaMA

Qwen3.6 27B on Dual RTX 5060 Ti 16GB with vLLM: ~60 tok/s, 204k Context Working

A user ran Qwen3.6 27B with vLLM on dual RTX 5060 Ti 16GB cards, reaching ~62–66 tok/s at 8K. The setup used 32GB VRAM, TP=2, fp8 KV cache, MTP 3 tokens, and a 204800 context window. The tight part is memory: after a 168k prefill, each GPU used ~15.65GiB with max_num_seqs=1.

Why it matters: A user ran Qwen3.6 27B on two RTX 5060 Ti 16GB cards with vLLM and measured 62–66 tok/s at 8K context, with the exact tensor-parallel, fp8 KV cache and MTP settings listed.