Tim Gowers on what kind of maths LLMs are good at—and why “counterexample” is a slippery label
OpenAI just claimed ten major solves in math and TCS, including the first non-sofic group and superexponential growth of multicolour Ramsey numbers. Gowers doesn't assess those results directly. Instead he asks whether LLMs are especially good at finding counterexamples—and immediately complicates the idea. Vinogradov's three-primes theorem can be phrased as a negated universal, but nobody calls it a counterexample. The real question is where the first “interesting” quantifier sits. The post doesn't settle LLM boundaries; it rules out bad answers and flags what to watch next.
Why it matters: Gowers posts immediately after OpenAI's 10-problem math breakthrough, not rehashing the news but offering an original analytical framework. Hits all three HKR axes with top-tier author authority. Score capped below 85 because it's an initial blog discussion, not a formal paper...