Two reviewers flagged fake authors in papers—both were accepted as orals anyway
I flagged two research papers for fake authors and both were accepted as orals
Caleb Robinson and Isaac Corley reviewed 22 ML conference submissions this summer. Fifteen—68%—contained fabricated citations, hallucinated author names, or obvious LLM-generated text. Two papers Isaac rejected for fake authors were accepted as orals anyway, on the condition that the references be fixed. They released a bib-audit tool and cited numbers: an estimated 146,900 hallucinated citations on arXiv and similar platforms in 2025, with 85.3% surviving into published versions; 21% of ICLR 2026 reviews were fully AI-generated. Their take: peer review is unpaid labor, and if authors won't even check their own references, there's no reason for reviewers to spend nights and weekends on it.
Why it matters: Two reviewers screened 22 machine learning conference submissions, found 15 with fabricated citations or invented authors, and two papers they rejected for fake authorship were still accepted as orals.