Lines of Code Got a Better Publicist
David Curlewis argues that Google, Anthropic, and OpenAI are all touting volume metrics like 'percent of code written by AI,' which is just lines-of-code counting with better PR. He contrasts earlier outcome claims (Copilot made tasks 55% faster) with today's unfalsifiable adoption numbers that rise regardless of real improvement. The post walks through conflicting research: METR first found experienced devs 19% slower with AI, then walked it back and abandoned the study design; an NBER survey of ~6,000 execs found ~90% reporting no measurable productivity impact. Anthropic simultaneously claims '8x more code' and published an RCT showing 17% lower comprehension with no significant productivity gain. Curlewis worries these numbers are driving layoffs—Block cut 40% of staff, Atlassian cut 10%, both explicitly citing AI as the rationale.
Why it matters: David Curlewis compares the AI code-share percentages touted by Google, Anthropic and OpenAI with Copilot's earlier verifiable claim of 55% faster, and argues these percentages are closer to PR language.