Skip to content
Trending storyPast story

AI can't write maintainable code, and people who rely on it won't learn either

1 report1 sourceupdated 7 days ago

What happened

Summary

作者 Alexandru Nedelcu 直接开喷:靠 AI 一口仙气(vibe-coding)堆出来的项目,时间一长都会烂成没法维护的屎山。核心问题在于,代码好不好维护、架构合不合理,没有即时反馈信号——坏味道可能要几个月甚至几年才会爆发,而现在的 AI 训练(比如强化学习)只看眼前奖励,根本学不会这种需要长期直觉的东西。他指出现有最强模型连“把大函...

Coverage

Follow the reports to see the story from different sides.

Sep 22
  1. Hacker News front page
    AI can't write maintainable code, and people who rely on it won't learn either

    Alexandru Nedelcu argues that vibe-coded projects inevitably decay into unmaintainable messes because maintainability has no instant reward signal for RL training—bad architecture takes months or years to surface. He notes that even SOTA models fail at extracting clarifying, reusable functions, and that most training data reflects the mediocre code found in the wild. The deeper risk is that developers who outsource both writing and reading to AI stop making choices, owning mistakes, and building the intuition that separates experts from advanced beginners. His prediction: more companies will start advertising a “NO-AI” policy as a competitive edge.