Gary Marcus gives Dario Amodei's AI pacing proposal two cheers out of three

Gary Marcus 评 Dario Amodei 的放慢 AI 发展提议：三份赞誉加两分怀疑

Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei published an essay urging the industry to pace frontier AI development, quickly endorsed by Sam Altman and Elon Musk. Gary Marcus applauds the transparency pledge and third-party evaluator access, but flags the essay's opening hype about AI curing cancer or taking down the internet. David Sacks and François Chollet suspect the real play is pulling up the ladder behind incumbents. The post does not detail concrete enforcement mechanisms or timelines.

Why it matters: Dario Amodei's long-form call to pace frontier AI, with Altman and Musk publicly endorsing, is a rare alignment event. Marcus's commentary adds concrete dissection rather than mere cheerleading. Score held below 85 because this is a reaction piece, not a primary release, and M...