AI raised the floor, but grading rubrics still penalize the ceiling
AI 抬高了下限,评分标准还在惩罚上限
Two large-scale RCTs show the same pattern: AI lifts the floor of student work while present, but once removed, performance drops, and traditional rubrics actively penalize deeper reasoning. In a Turkish high school math experiment, ChatGPT-assisted practice scores jumped 48%, yet closed-book exam scores fell 17% below the control group. In a Milan business writing study, students who spelled out failure conditions and causal mechanisms received systematically lower grades. The floor is borrowed from external compute; the ceiling only grows when rubrics reward it.
Why it matters: Two 1,000-person randomized trials show AI lifts practice scores up to 127% but drops closed-book test scores 17% once it's removed.