Four years in, I still don't trust LLMs for real software work
I Remain a Skeptic
Joshua Barretto, whose open-source libraries sit in FAANG dependency trees, still refuses to use LLMs for anything he cares about. Four years in, he sees no faster, cheaper, or more secure software—just a mountain of demoware. $1.5 trillion later, independent studies on top-level productivity gains are still missing. The AI-generated PRs he receives remain unfit to merge, and frontier models miss obvious bugs that hobbyists catch. His core point: code is an input to development, not an output, and measuring productivity by lines written leads straight to unmaintainable slop.
Why it matters: An open-source maintainer whose code FAANG companies depend on questions whether LLMs can write serious software, after four years of watching and $1.5 trillion in spending.