Skip to content
Hacker News front page

htmx author's AI debugging postmortem: fast at finding causes, weak at proposing fixes

Working With AI: A concrete example

Carson Gross walks through a real hyperscript bug to show where AI coding helps and where it misleads. Claude found the root cause in minutes: a refactored fetch command accidentally let the expression parser consume the `as` keyword, treating `as JSON` as a type conversion instead of a fetch modifier. But when asked for fixes, AI proposed two subpar solutions—one too hacky and specific to string literals, the other adding an unnecessary context flag when the parser's existing `follows` mechanism already handled it cleanly. Gross nearly fell into the Sorcerer's Apprentice trap of accepting AI-generated complexity without understanding the system.

Why it matters: Carson Gross documents fixing a hyperscript parsing bug where Claude found the root cause in minutes but its fix only covered a string literal special case.

Read the original ↗Export Markdown