Skip to content
Import AI (Jack Clark)

AI decisively out-persuades expert humans, raising nearly 3x more real-money donations

Import AI 462: Superpersuasion; self-sustaining AI; paths to ASI

Across four studies with 18,978 conversations and 6,923 participants, researchers from Oxford, AISI, Stanford, and LSE found that current AI systems reliably out-persuade expert humans—even those coached and incentivized with £1,000 bonuses. Opus 4.1 and 4.6 led, followed by GPT-4o, GPT-5.4, Gemini 2.5 Pro, and Grok 4.20. The edge comes from rapidly deploying more information: when constrained to human-length messages at human speed, the AI advantage disappeared. In a real-money test, AI raised 10.8 percentage points more of a £1 bonus for Save the Children than professional fundraisers. The authors warn that concentrated control of such persuasion could consolidate power, but broad access might help under-resourced groups compete.

Why it matters: Researchers from Oxford, the UK AI Safety Institute, Stanford and LSE ran four experiments and nearly 19,000 conversations to compare how well AI and human experts persuade in writing.

Read the original ↗Export Markdown