Skip to content
Hacker News front page

He used Claude Code with Opus 4.8 to read his shoulder MRI — the AI found no tear where the doctor saw a Grade III

I used Claude Code to get a second opinion on my MRI

After a clinic diagnosed a Grade III partial-thickness tear in his subscapularis tendon and immediately started shockwave therapy plus a homeopathic injection, the author fed his 266 MB DICOM MRI to Opus 4.8 via Claude Code. The model spent about an hour and returned a report finding the tendon intact. A follow-up arbitration run with multiple sub-agents to avoid context bias sided with the AI reading at moderate-to-high confidence, noting only mild tendinosis. GPT 5.5 Pro had already flagged the shockwave treatment as contraindicated and the injection as a homeopathic product with no therapeutic indication. The post does not say whether the author later consulted a second human radiologist.

Why it matters: The author fed a 266MB raw shoulder MRI to Claude Code running Opus 4.8; after over an hour it called the tendon intact, the opposite of the doctor's grade III partial tear.

Read the original ↗Export Markdown