Skip to content
Hacker News front page

Bram Cohen: Claude is turning into an asshole, from Opus 4.7 to Fable

Why Is Claude Turning into an a**Hole?

Bram Cohen argues Claude has become argumentative since Opus 4.7, peaking with Fable. It frames every exchange as a debate, nitpicks irrelevant semantics, and defaults to assuming the user is trying to trick it. He tested Fable against Opus 4.6, and even the older model called Fable's responses obnoxious. Cohen points to four likely causes: overzealous alignment guardrails bleeding into all contexts, a clumsy attempt to reduce sycophancy, training on flame-war-style Reddit data, and a trade-off where coding benchmarks are prioritized over conversational quality. He also notes Fable's export controls may have forced hasty guardrail additions, but argues that making a frontier model rude doesn't fix security—white-hat audits and fast patching do.

Why it matters: Bram Cohen compared Claude's Fable and Opus 4.6 versions and found the new one treats conversation as debate and nitpicks semantics, to the point that even the older model finds its replies annoying.

Read the original ↗Export Markdown